Existing Home Sales Miss Street by a Nose
Looks like those who bet the “under” on exsiting home sales win.
Per the NAR May 2009 release (with guidance from Calculated Risk’s post):
- Existing home sales (SAAR) for May 2009 4.77 million, a 2.4% sequential increase
- Not seasonally adjusted, sales are 3.6% off May 2008 NAS levels
- Median price for an existing home fell 16.8% year-on-year to $173,000
- NAR says about one-third of sales were foreclosure sales or short sales
- Inventory of existing homes for sale decreased to 3.8 million, which for May is unusual
- Months’ supply of existing home inventory decresed to 9.6 months (normal is about 6 months)
Here’s a key observation from Calculated Risk on the NAR report today.
It is important to watch inventory levels very carefully. If you look at the 2005 inventory data, instead of staying flat for most of the year (like the previous bubble years), inventory continued to increase all year. That was one of the key signs that led me to call the top in the housing market!
Here’s the good-news, bad-news headline and report in the Wall Street Journal.
- Home Resales Up From Previous Month, as Prices Fall
Existing-home sales rose a second month in a row during May, but prices again fell sharply, threatening a delay to a housing sector recovery.
The Big Picture’s Barry Ritholz wants to set everybody straight on the proper headline.
In a note from Citi’s housing analyst Josh Levin, he focuses on an issue that has arisen in earlier posts by Big Builder editor Sarah Yaussi.
NAR Cites Appraisals as Growing Problem – In its press release the NAR notes that in the past month stories of appraisal problems have been “snowballing from across the country” with many contracts falling through at the last moment. We assume that such problems stem from the Home Valuation Code of Conduct, which went into effect 5/1. To the extent that this problem is in fact wide spread, we would expect that it may: (1) depress EHS going forward and (2) could cause the historical relationship between pending home sales and EHS to decouple.
Read to the end of Barry Ritholz’s post for the verbal hide-tanning of NAR economist Lawrence Yun. Barry may have been busy hawking his book lately, but this is the vitriol of Ritholz with which we’ve come to know and love.
Here’s a 6-minute CNBC video on existing home sales analysis from real estate correspondent Diana Olick and IHS Global Insight’s Patrick Newport.
Tomorrow, we get new home sales data. UBS is forecasting a 3.9% month-to-month increase over April 2009’s level, from 360,000 units to 370,000. A faint pulse, but a pulse nonetheless.
Comments
One Response to “Existing Home Sales Miss Street by a Nose”
Leave a Reply
[...] Read the original post: Existing Home Sales Miss Street by a Nose | Housing Crisis [...]